I play a lot of sport, and wear almost exclusively Asics trainers (sneakers if you like the other kind of English) to do so. In fact I only wear one pair of trainers, to the gym, to classes and for netball - which might be a mistake. One pair of trainers used to make my toes go dead sometimes, usually when running. A woman I was playing netball with at the time re-laced my trainers and that stopped the problem. My new trainers are giving me the same problem, and luckily I was able to dig out those old ones and copy the lacing - so here it is for posterity (and for next time I have this problem and can't remember how to do it).

Lace the bottom of the shoe as usual, then with 2 holes to go, thread down into the shoe.

Come up through the top hole on the opposite side.

Staying on the same side, go back inwards through the hole you just missed out.

Finally, thread each end through the loop on the outside of the opposite side of the shoe (see why I included pictures? This is tricky to explain)

I'm not sure why this works for me, I have a high instep so perhaps it relieves pressure on a key point? Anyway, if this works for you, or if you have any tips - leave a comment!